Top pick
Five Torches Deep
Pick Five Torches Deep when your table wants 5e to feel more dangerous, resource-driven, and old-school while keeping enough familiar structure to make the switch easy.
Best 5e Compatible TTRPGs
5e-compatible TTRPGs keep the D&D 5e rules base, assumptions, or conversion path close enough that an existing 5e table can carry over its habits. Use this guide when you want a game that still feels legible to 5e players, not just a broader fantasy game with a twenty-sided die.
Start with the three strongest anchors currently in the directory. Five Torches Deep is the 5e-to-OSR bridge for dangerous dungeon play, Brancalonia uses the 5e base for low-magic spaghetti fantasy and capers, and Carbon 2185 moves familiar d20 expectations into cyberpunk jobs, augmentations, guns, and corporate pressure.
If your group is leaving 5e because it wants different math, different GM procedures, or old-school rulings rather than compatibility, the related d20 and OSR categories will be more useful. This list is for games where 5e familiarity is genuinely part of the pitch.
3 games All categories
Top picks
Best games in this category
Quick starting points if you want the clearest expressions of what 5e Compatible games do well.
Top pick
Brancalonia
Choose Brancalonia if your table wants 5e compatibility but a new cultural and tonal frame: lowborn trouble, Italian-inspired folklore, rough comedy, and comic danger.
Top pick
Carbon 2185
Use Carbon 2185 when players want to keep a 5e-like rules foundation but move the actual campaign into chrome, firearms, hacking, and corporate cyberpunk pressure.
Compare
How to choose the right 5e Compatible TTRPG
How to choose a 5e-compatible TTRPG
Start by deciding what your table wants to keep from 5e. If the answer is familiar character builds and encounter rhythm, choose Five Torches Deep for a lighter dungeon crawl or Brancalonia for a distinctive fantasy campaign that still speaks 5e. If the table wants 5e-shaped procedures in a different genre, Carbon 2185 is the clearer fit.
If your group mainly wants a break from 5e assumptions, browse nearby d20 and OSR categories instead. Those games can be excellent recommendations for 5e players, but they solve a different problem than direct 5e compatibility.
FAQ
Questions players ask
Which 5e-compatible TTRPG should my table play first?
Start with Five Torches Deep if your group wants 5e to feel more dangerous and old-school, Brancalonia if you want a distinctive low-magic fantasy setting, or Carbon 2185 if the table wants cyberpunk without learning an unrelated rules language.
Why is this 5e-compatible list short?
Because 5e-compatible should mean more than “a game a 5e group might enjoy.” A game belongs here when it stays close to the 5e base, conversion path, or table vocabulary. Broader d20 games, OSR retroclones, and Shadowdark-compatible games may be useful next steps for 5e players, but they answer a different browsing question.
What is the difference between 5e-compatible, d20, and OSR?
5e-compatible means the game intentionally keeps 5e assumptions or conversion paths close. d20 is a broader roll-plus-modifier family. OSR points toward older D&D procedures, danger, rulings, and exploration priorities. These labels overlap sometimes, but they are not interchangeable.
Where should I look for non-5e D&D alternatives?
Use the d20 System category for broader roll-plus-modifier fantasy and the OSR category for old-school danger, rulings, exploration, and module compatibility. Those are better paths for many games that 5e players might like but that are not actually built around 5e compatibility.
More to compare
More 5e Compatible TTRPGs to compare
Brancalonia
Brancalonia uses the 5e base for low-magic spaghetti fantasy, capers, brawls, folklore, and scrappy knaves. It is strongest when your group wants compatibility plus a campaign tone that feels meaningfully different.
Carbon 2185
Carbon 2185 is the genre swing: cyberpunk jobs, augmentations, guns, hacking, and corporate dystopia built on a d20 foundation 5e players can recognize.
Five Torches Deep
Five Torches Deep is the clearest bridge from 5e to OSR play. It keeps familiar fantasy language but pushes light, supplies, exploration, and risk much closer to old-school dungeon pressure.
Keep browsing
Related categories
System
d20 System
Browse d20 System if you want broader roll-plus-modifier fantasy and D&D-family alternatives that are not necessarily 5e-compatible.
System
Old-School Renaissance (OSR)
Browse OSR if your real goal is danger, rulings, exploration, and faster dungeon procedures rather than 5e compatibility.
Genre
Fantasy
Browse Fantasy if you want the wider genre rather than games built around the 5e rules base.
Mechanic
Class-based
Browse Class-Based if familiar character roles matter more than direct compatibility with 5e rules.