Choose Spelljammer to keep your D&D characters, Dark Matter to add sci-fi to 5E, Esper Genesis to rebuild with familiar rules, or Starfinder 2e to switch systems. The first decision isn’t which game has the best ships. It’s how much D&D your group wants to keep.
These 4 options differ in character carryover, starter books, ship combat, space travel, and learning effort. Check the edition before buying: Dark Matter has separate 5.0E and 5.5E product lines, while Starfinder 2e uses a different rules system.
Quick Comparison
| Game | Character carryover | Ships and travel | Starting books | Learning effort |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Spelljammer | Keep most of a 5E character sheet | Magical ships, boarding fights, and fantasy worlds; lighter ship rules | Spelljammer: Adventures in Space plus D&D core rules | Low |
| Dark Matter | Keep much of 5E; check character options and gear | Crew roles, ship upgrades, alien worlds, and magic-powered tech | Matching-edition supplement plus D&D rules | Low to moderate |
| Esper Genesis | Rebuild with sci-fi classes and powers using familiar d20 rules | Crew actions, ship customization, and space missions | Core Manual; no D&D books required | Moderate |
| Starfinder 2e | Keep the concept, rebuild the sheet | Science fantasy, tactical encounters, and cinematic ship combat | Player Core and GM Core | High |
Before committing, try a 1–2-session mission with a ground fight, a ship scene, and a travel challenge. That gives the group a chance to test both the rules and the kind of space campaign it wants.
D&D in Space: Compare 4 RPG Options
Spelljammer: Adventures in Space
Spelljammer takes D&D into space without leaving its fantasy roots behind. Ships run on magic, not engines: a spellcaster uses a magical helm to pilot through Wildspace and the Astral Sea. Think fantasy-first space travel, without fuel calculations or orbital mechanics.
Starting Books, Existing Characters, and Rules Changes
For an existing D&D group, the main draw is simple: your characters stay mostly intact. Fifth-edition characters can generally keep their classes, levels, subclasses, equipment, spells, and proficiencies.
The collection contains three 64-page books:
- Astral Adventurer’s Guide covers setting rules, ship procedures, magic items, spells, and space-themed options.
- Boo’s Astral Menagerie offers more than 60 creatures.
- Light of Xaryxis provides a 12-episode adventure for characters around levels 5–8.
For a home campaign, start with Astral Adventurer’s Guide and the D&D core rules. Add Boo’s Astral Menagerie for more encounters. You only need Light of Xaryxis if you want to run the included adventure.
The collection assumes 2014 5E. To use it with the 2024 rules, check species, backgrounds, feats, weapon terms, and spell interactions.
Ship Combat, Space Travel, and Campaign Fit
Ships carry breathable air in an air envelope and have gravity planes, so characters can move normally on open decks. In Wildspace, air, gravity, and drifting hazards all matter; in the Astral Sea, breathing is no longer an issue. Before play, agree on how rescue attempts, flight, and forced movement work around a gravity plane.
Ship combat builds on normal D&D encounters with vessel statistics, weapons, movement, components, and crew procedures. It isn't a detailed naval simulation. Decide who pilots, fires weapons, repairs damage, and boards enemy vessels. You'll also need to clarify initiative and how disabled components work.
Detailed navigation and fleet battles call for extra DM procedures. Keep combat centered on the players' vessel and handle other ships in broader terms. The tradeoff is D&D continuity over ship-system depth. Spelljammer fits groups that want boarding actions and strange-world exploration more than technical ship play.
If your group wants more technology and less magic, the next options move further into sci-fi while keeping a familiar d20 base.
Dark Matter: Fifth-Edition Rules for Sci-Fi Adventures
Mage Hand Press’s Dark Matter takes the middle ground: it keeps 5E while moving beyond Spelljammer’s fantasy-first approach into guns, advanced gear, alien worlds, and customizable starships. It’s science fantasy, with magic powering the technology.
Edition, Required Books, and Character Options
This review covers Dark Matter 5.0E, built for 2014-era fifth edition. You’ll need the 2014 Player’s Handbook and DM rules alongside it. Dark Matter doesn’t replace the full D&D rules framework.
Existing characters mostly carry over, though you should check species, backgrounds, feats, armor, firearms, and tech proficiencies against the book’s options.
That keeps conversion work fairly light. At the table, the main rules to learn are ship roles and ship-scale combat.
Ship Combat, Crew Roles, and Customization
Ship battles give players clear jobs: pilot, gunner, engineer, and captain, with room for a separate fighter pilot. These roles use fifth-edition-style initiative and action economy, but ships have their own durability scale: 1 Mega Hit Point equals 100 normal hit points. The engineer handles the shields. Players still need to learn their role actions and the ship-scale rules.
Ship-building procedures cover crew manifests, hulls, systems, weapons, and fighter bays. Those choices suit frontier expeditions, bounty hunting, and mercenary contracts. The vessel becomes shared party equipment that players can upgrade over time.
Start with a prebuilt or lightly customized ship, assign roles before combat, and run a short practice encounter. Customization gives players more decisions to make, but it also means more bookkeeping.
Esper Genesis: Sci-Fi With Familiar D20 Rules
Esper Genesis gives your group a full sci-fi rebuild while keeping familiar d20 rules. It’s a standalone sci-fi RPG built on a 5E-like engine, not a D&D supplement. You’ll use its character options and setting assumptions rather than simply add to D&D.
Core Books, Character Choices, and D&D Conversion
Start with the Core Manual. Add the Threats Database for more foes and the Master Technician’s Guide for advanced options, ship construction, and campaign tools.
Checks, saves, proficiency, advantage/disadvantage, initiative, actions, and levels should feel familiar. Character creation brings bigger changes, with different species, classes, and powers. Channeling replaces D&D’s spell list with Talents, Techniques, and a separate resource system.
Keep your character concept, then rebuild the sheet using the Core Manual. Don’t assume a direct conversion will work: D&D classes, subclasses, spells, magic items, and equipment each need GM approval.
Ship Encounters, Space Travel, and New Rules
Ship play pairs a familiar action economy with new crew duties. It’s part of the system, not an add-on. The Core Manual covers ship encounters and travel, with pilot, gunner, and technician actions handling movement, weapons, repairs, and systems.
Players need to learn their crew actions. The GM also needs to know the rules for ship movement, damage, repairs, and zero-g play. The Master Technician’s Guide adds more options for customization, starbases, larger-scale combat, exploration, and celestial navigation.
For your first session, use a prebuilt vessel, one navigation challenge, and one short ship encounter. Save construction and extensive upgrades for later. Expect a moderate learning effort: familiar resolution rules help, but dedicated science-fiction adventures with fifth-edition-style d20 play still come with new classes, powers, gear, and crew procedures to learn.
Starfinder Second Edition: A Different Tactical System
Starfinder Second Edition means rebuilding your D&D characters, not converting their sheets. Paizo’s standalone science-fantasy game uses Pathfinder Second Edition as its base, not D&D. Expect advanced technology, alien civilizations, and magic side by side - not hard science fiction. First-edition Starfinder characters, gear, and ship rules don’t carry over, making character creation your first major reset.
Starting Books, Character Rebuilding, and Combat
Start with Starfinder Player Core for character creation and player rules, plus Starfinder GM Core for encounter tools and GM procedures. Alien Core adds 200+ creatures but is optional when starting out. Galaxy Guide provides setting lore, while Galactic Ancestries adds 21 ancestries. Neither is required at launch.
Player Core includes six core classes - envoy, mystic, operative, solarian, soldier, and witchwarper - and 10 ancestries. Only your character concept carries over. You’ll rebuild the character from scratch, and subclasses and magic items won’t necessarily have one-to-one replacements.
Combat uses three actions, separate reactions, and degrees of success. Players need to learn action costs, attack penalties, conditions, and skill actions. Feats and positioning matter, so GMs should follow Starfinder’s encounter-building guidance rather than rely on D&D difficulty assumptions. Starship combat uses the same tactical framework.
Published Spaceship Rules, Exploration, and Learning Effort
GM Core includes Second Edition cinematic starship combat, plus rules for hacking, research, chases, and infiltration. Galaxy Guide adds setting depth and exploration support.
Run a character-build session, then teach movement, cover, attacks, and skill use. Once players have those basics down, introduce ship combat and more complex conditions.
Final Comparison: D&D Compatibility, Ships, and Learning Effort
Compatibility comes down to how much of your D&D game you can bring into space. Keeping a character sheet isn’t the same as keeping a character concept. The table separates the two and assumes your group already knows D&D fifth edition.
| Game and edition | Genre | Character carryover | Ship rules | Exploration | What to buy | Learning demand / best fit |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Spelljammer, D&D 5E | Space fantasy | Usually keep classes, levels, spells, and gear with little rebuilding. | Official ships and spacefaring rules; lighter procedures leave room for GM rulings. | Wildspace, the Astral Sea, ports, and fantasy hazards | Spelljammer: Adventures in Space - Astral Adventurer’s Guide, Boo’s Astral Menagerie, and Light of Xaryxis. | Low; keep D&D and continue an existing campaign. |
| Dark Matter, 5E version | Sci-fi adventures with fantasy elements | Mostly familiar 5E character rules, though some options change. | Crew roles, ship actions, travel rules, and customization | Planets, stations, missions, and technology-driven hazards | The Dark Matter supplement; check the edition before buying. | Moderate; add science-fiction tools to 5E. |
| Esper Genesis, fifth-edition-compatible core rules | Dedicated science fiction | Familiar d20 procedures; classes, powers, and gear may need rebuilding. | Published ship rules with crew procedures and customization | Alien environments, travel, and mission-based exploration | Its core rulebook; D&D core books aren’t required. | Moderate; keep familiar resolution rules while switching to a dedicated sci-fi game. |
| Starfinder 2e | Science fantasy | Keep the concept, not the sheet; rebuild from scratch. | GM Core provides cinematic starship combat; Tech Core adds tactical starship combat and rules for building, crewing, and upgrading ships. | Structured support for space travel, hacking, research, chases, infiltration, and exploration across the galaxy | Player Core and GM Core to start. | High; rebuild in a different tactical system. |
Match your group’s preferred level of D&D carryover to a row, then use the guidance below to narrow your choice.
Which Game Fits Your D&D Group?
Spelljammer keeps the most D&D intact. Dark Matter and Esper Genesis keep familiar 5E mechanics but shift the genre. Starfinder 2e means moving to a different system entirely.
Once you’ve picked a system, test what your group expects from it before committing to a full campaign.
Before You Start: A Campaign Checklist
Before buying anything, agree on what to keep, change, or rebuild from D&D. Decide whether ships will serve as transportation, create occasional complications, or become the main battlefield. Check conversion support for your exact D&D edition - not every “5E-compatible” product supports the same rules.
Before buying supplements, try a one- or two-session mission. Include a ground encounter, a ship scene, an exploration challenge, and a short character-creation exercise. Use those sessions to judge what your group enjoyed keeping and what it enjoyed learning before committing to a campaign.
FAQs
How can I introduce space travel into an ongoing D&D campaign?
Start small with a space station or an isolated outpost. Build your story around factions and conflicts to keep things moving, adding space-themed stakes where they fit.
Bring in travel, discovery, and hazards with a new story arc. Give each session a clear obstacle, and let the world respond to what players do. If you want a familiar d20-based framework, Starfinder has rules for starships and advanced technology.
How can every player contribute during starship combat?
Give every player a defined crew role so their decisions matter each turn. Engineers can manage shields or weapon power. Communications specialists can coordinate targeting or interference, weapon operators can fire, and support crew can handle repairs or healing.
Give each role meaningful choices: suppress enemies, flank, disable systems, or support allies. Encourage players to share updates and coordinate tactics so everyone stays involved and no single player takes over.
What should we test before committing to a space RPG?
Test whether your group enjoys the campaign’s repeat activities: jobs and trade, horror survival, tactical missions, exploration, politics, or cyberpunk-style street play. Pay attention to how the rules support those activities. Check the learning curve, especially for ship combat, travel and exploration pressures, and rules for technology and alien life.
Decide whether you want a one-shot, a short arc, or a long sandbox campaign. Give the game several sessions before judging whether the mechanics - not just the premise - are fun.



