Cthulhu Dark

Cthulhu Dark is Graham Walmsley's rules-light Lovecraftian horror game. Ordinary people roll up to three d6, risk their minds on the Insight die and cannot fight the monsters. The book has four settings with adventures.

At-a-glance

Cosmic horror • Up to three d6, highest counts • Insight track to 6 • No fighting monsters • Four settings with adventures • Best as a one-shot

Store links are affiliate links.

Cthulhu Dark

Cthulhu Dark is a rules-light Lovecraftian horror game by Graham Walmsley. It began in 2010 as a four-page leaflet and grew, after a 2017 Kickstarter, into a book of about 200 pages with the same short rules, a long section of GM advice and four settings with an adventure each. Characters are ordinary people who cannot fight the monsters. They can only investigate, run, hide and slowly learn too much.

It is best for groups who want tense, bleak one-shot investigations with almost no rules to learn, and for Call of Cthulhu fans who want a lighter, faster game. It is a poor fit for groups who want combat, character builds or a long campaign where characters grow stronger.

What the game is

Cthulhu Dark is cosmic horror about powerless people. The publisher's description says you cannot beat the alien horrors and cannot fight them; you can only watch, run, hide and fear. The book also pushes past Lovecraft's own class prejudice. Its settings cast players as the poor and marginalised, and in its stories the horror tends to come from the top of society down.

Publication history and editions

  • Original leaflet (2010): four pages of rules, where the third die was called the Insanity die.
  • Kickstarter (2017): 19th Level covered the campaign's launch on June 1, 2017. It funded the full book.
  • Full book: about 200 pages. The PDF has been on DriveThruRPG since January 2021 at $12, with a 4.9 rating. Indie Press Revolution sells the print and PDF bundle.
  • Cthulhu Dark 0: a roughly 100-page early version for backers with only the London setting. Taskerland notes it can cost more than the full book.

Walmsley wrote the rules, the advice, London 1851 and Mumbai 2037. Kathryn Jenkins wrote Arkham 1692 and Helen Gould wrote Jaiwo 2017. Interior art is by Matteo Bocci and maps are by Stentor Danielson.

What you need to play

  • The book or PDF.
  • A few six-sided dice per player, with one in a different colour to track Insight.
  • One GM and a small group of players.
  • One of the included adventures, or a Cthulhu scenario from another game. Conversion is easy because there are no stats.

Core rules and play structure

When you try something risky, roll one die if a normal human could do it. Add a second die if it fits your occupation. Add a third, the Insight die, if you are willing to risk your mind to succeed. The highest die sets how well it goes. In Taskerland's summary of the book, a 4 means you succeed, a 5 adds a piece of hidden lore and a 6 reveals something only the supernatural could tell you.

The GM, or another player, can roll a failure die when failing would make the scene more interesting. Fighting a supernatural creature does not get a roll. It means death. Fights with ordinary humans use the same roll as any other task.

Characters and advancement

A character is a name and an occupation, so you do not need a character sheet. Each setting lists occupations and pregenerated characters. There is no advancement. Insight starts at 1 and only climbs as characters face the unknown. When Insight reaches 6, the character is lost to the horror, and the player narrates how. Characters can lower Insight by destroying traces of the Mythos, such as burning occult books.

Signature mechanics

  • The Insight die: roll it to see if your understanding of the horror grows. If you roll above your current Insight, it goes up by one.
  • Dice pool of up to three: human, occupation and Insight dice, with the highest result counting.
  • Failure dice: a way for the GM or players to add complications.
  • Suppressing the Mythos: destroying evidence of the supernatural pushes Insight back down.

What play feels like

Sessions move fast because rolls are rare and quick. Tension builds as Insight climbs, and the most important choice is often whether to risk your mind for one more clue. Players know their characters are probably doomed, which gives the endings weight. The included adventures are fairly linear, closer to classic Call of Cthulhu scenarios than to sandboxes.

Running the game

Most of the book is advice for the GM. It covers describing scenes, building mysteries and using recurring images the book calls creeping horrors, and it suggests themes for various Mythos creatures. It also suggests pacing a session so the group reaches Insight 3 about halfway through and 4 near the end. Prep is light: read a scenario, note its key clues and images, and pick pregenerated characters.

Campaign fit

Cthulhu Dark is built for one-shots. The book does offer campaign options, such as resetting Insight to 1 for survivors who recover, and advice on linking the four adventures. Taskerland ran short campaigns that way but felt the game would need extra rules for long play.

Reception and awards

DriveThruRPG customers rate it 4.9. Taskerland's March 2025 review called it "a great rules-light spin on Lovecraftian investigation" and praised the GM advice, while finding the Mumbai 2037 adventure unfinished. The reviewer also saw it as a likely influence on Trophy Dark, whose rules are very similar. 19th Level, writing in 2017, compared it to Call of Cthulhu and Trail of Cthulhu as a lighter way to play.

Where it is strongest

  • Rules you can teach in two minutes.
  • Insight creates real dread.
  • Excellent advice for running any horror game.
  • Four distinct settings, from Victorian London to near-future Mumbai.

Where it can frustrate groups

  • No combat with monsters, only death.
  • Little character growth.
  • Linear adventures.
  • Campaign play needs house rules.

Content and safety notes

Expect death, madness, violence and grim social themes. The London adventure deals with the exploitation of the poor and a stolen newborn. Talk about limits before play, especially for one-shots with new players.

Best starting path

Run London 1851 and its adventure, Screams of the Children, as a one-shot. Use the pregenerated characters, keep the dice in the middle of the table and let the green Insight die do the work.

Research notes

Last checked November 2, 2026. Price, rating and release date are from DriveThruRPG. Editions, credits, rules and settings are from Taskerland (March 27, 2025). Kickstarter timing is from 19th Level (June 1, 2017).