Best Left Buried
Best Left Buried is SoulMuppet Publishing's rules-light fantasy horror TTRPG about Cryptdiggers, professional dungeon divers who come back richer but broken. Checks are 2d6 plus Brawn, Wit or Will against 9; Vigour tracks wounds, Grip tracks nerve and magic, and lost Grip returns only as lasting Injuries or Afflictions. The GM is the Doomsayer, and the Deeper hardcover collects all three core books.
Fantasy horror dungeon crawl • 2d6 + stat vs 9 • GM (Doomsayer) + group • Rules-lite • Low prep • Lethal, coin-flip death
Store links are affiliate links.

Best Left Buried is a rules-light fantasy horror TTRPG from SoulMuppet Publishing in which, as the publisher puts it, "the monsters are scary, and you are scared." Players are Cryptdiggers, professional dungeon divers who go into monster-filled Crypts for money and usually come back broken. It is a strong pick for a GM and group who want dungeon crawling that feels like horror, with simple 2d6 checks and lasting mental and physical damage.
It is not for tables that want heroic characters, balanced fights or a long list of class powers. Characters can die from a single bad coin flip or lose their minds to what they see, and the game expects players to retreat when things look grim.
What the game is
Best Left Buried is credited to Zachary Cox with Nicholas Spence, with art by Ben Brown. It is often filed under the OSR, and it shares the OSR's focus on dangerous dungeons and GM rulings, but its rules are its own rather than a D&D clone. The GM is called the Doomsayer, and the canonical setting is the Thirteen Duchies of Lendal, although the Crypts work in any dark fantasy world.
Publication history and editions
- Cryptdigger's Guide to Survival: the core rulebook, with character creation, rules, monsters and magic for players and the Doomsayer.
- Doomsayer's Guide to Horror: a 108-page GM book on building dungeons, running games and telling stories, with the sample adventure Lowlands of Internment, setting notes on the Thirteen Duchies of Lendal, and rules for treasure, experience and magic items.
- Hunter's Guide to Monsters: monster mythology, monster templates, a bestiary, 100 new Adaptations and rules for crafting treasure from defeated monsters.
- Best Left Buried: Deeper (2020): a 328-page hardcover compiling all three books. The Gaming Gang listed it at $46 in hardcover in 2022.
An Expanded Character Options supplement adds dwarves, elves and small folk, and SoulMuppet has released a line of Crypt adventures.
What you need to play
You need the rules, a handful of six-sided dice, a coin and a GM. When checked on October 29, 2026, the SoulMuppet store listed Best Left Buried: Deeper from £20 (PDF, with print-and-PDF options), free character sheets and a free Zini Edition, and noted that physical orders currently ship only to the US while it changes fulfilment providers. The itch.io edition of Deeper was $25 for the complete PDF set.
Core rules and play structure
Characters have three stats, Brawn, Wit and Will, set to +2, +1 and +0 at creation. Almost every roll is a Stat Check: 2d6 plus a stat, succeeding on 9 or more. Upper Hand adds a die and drops the lowest, while Against the Odds adds a die and drops the highest. Observation Checks use a flat 2d6 against 9 to spot hidden things and avoid surprise.
Combat runs in ten-second rounds with abstract Zones for movement and range. Attacks are 3d6 plus Brawn or Wit against the enemy's target number. If two of the dice plus the stat hit the target, the third die is the damage. A damage die of 6 is a critical hit that causes a random Injury.
Characters and advancement
Every Cryptdigger has an Archetype, such as Believer, Cabalist, Cutthroat, Dastard, Everyman, Freeblade, Outcast, Scholar, Protagonist or Veteran. Each gives a short concept, three or four abilities or drawbacks and suggested Advancements. Characters gain Advancements as they survive Crypts, and Vigour grows with them. The Ynas Midgard review describes the Cabalist, for example, as shrugging off the first Grip loss each day and starting with a random Affliction.
Signature mechanics
- Vigour and the coin: Vigour is physical health. When a Cryptdigger drops to zero, you flip a coin, and tails means death.
- Grip: stamina, magic and sanity in one pool. It fuels Exertion and some Advancements, and horrific sights drain it. If it runs out, the character is lost to shock, madness or worse.
- Consequences: lost Grip comes back only by taking a lasting Consequence, such as an Injury or Affliction, so each Crypt leaves its mark.
What play feels like
A delve is slow and nervous. Players poke at rooms, solve strange puzzles and decide whether a monster is worth fighting at all. The 2d6 against 9 checks mean failure is common, and one fight can turn deadly quickly. Between the dangers, SoulMuppet's weird monsters and environments set the tone: the horror comes from the unknown and from watching your character fray.
Running the game
The Doomsayer's Guide is one of the line's strengths, with advice on designing Crypts, pacing horror and handling treasure and experience. Prep is light if you use a published Crypt or the sample adventure, and the monster templates make it easy to twist familiar creatures. The Gaming Gang found the rules easy for new players and GMs, and full of ideas worth borrowing for other fantasy games.
Campaign fit
The game works for a single Crypt, but its Advancements and Consequences reward a series of delves, as characters grow stronger and more damaged at the same time. Expect some turnover: new recruits join as others die or break.
Reception and awards
The Gaming Gang (October 2022) scored Deeper 9 out of 10, saying it doesn't reinvent the wheel but knows exactly what kind of game it wants to be. Ynas Midgard's detailed 2020 review praised its system and archetypes. The usual caveats are the high lethality and the fact that it is less of a straight OSR clone than its labelling suggests. It has no major awards.
Where it is strongest
- Horror-first dungeon crawling with scary, strange monsters
- Simple 2d6 checks that new players learn in minutes
- Grip and Consequences that leave lasting scars on characters
- Strong GM advice and a free Zini Edition to try
Where it can frustrate groups
- Characters die or break often
- Few options for players who like to build characters
- Check odds make failure frequent
- Physical orders limited to the US at the time of checking
Content and safety notes
Expect gore, body horror, madness and characters losing their minds or their lives. The standard rules list suicide among the ways a character with no Grip can be lost, so agree on lines and veils before play and decide how such outcomes are described.
Best starting path
Download the free Zini Edition and character sheets, run one short Crypt, and see how your group likes the Grip and coin-flip death rules. If they stick, buy Deeper for the full GM advice and bestiary.
Research notes
Last checked October 29, 2026. Prices and shipping notes are from the SoulMuppet store and itch.io on that date; rules details are from the Ynas Midgard review and the publisher's description.