How to Mix History and Fantasy in RPGs

Blending history and fantasy in RPGs creates immersive worlds that feel both grounded and magical. Here’s how you can do it effectively:

Key Takeaways:

• Start with History: Use real historical settings like ancient Rome or the Renaissance to provide structure and realism.
• Add Fantasy Elements: Introduce magic, mythical creatures, or alternate events that fit naturally into the chosen era.
• Balance Accuracy and Creativity: Focus on atmosphere rather than strict historical details. Use "what if" scenarios to reimagine events with a fantastical twist.
• Choose the Right Period: Pick an era that aligns with your campaign's themes - conflict-heavy periods like the Hundred Years’ War work well.
• Respect the Setting: Align magic with the beliefs of the time (e.g., witches in the Salem trials or Viking seidr magic).
• Engage Players: Let them shape the narrative and explore alternate histories while respecting historical context.

Quick Comparison of Genres:

What is Historical Fantasy in RPGs

Defining Historical Fantasy

Historical fantasy in RPGs blends magic and myth with real-world historical settings, creating a unique narrative experience. These games often take place in periods before the 20th century, drawing inspiration from subgenres like Arthurian legends, Celtic folklore, or the Dark Ages. The result is a fantastical twist on familiar historical contexts.

In these settings, magic can either subtly influence events behind the scenes or dramatically reshape history. For example, imagine battle mages fighting for Napoleon or dragons soaring above Civil War battlefields. Another common approach involves creating fictional worlds that mirror historical periods, allowing for creative freedom while maintaining a sense of familiarity.

To clarify how historical fantasy stands apart from other genres, let’s break it down:

This comparison highlights the unique niche historical fantasy occupies, combining historical authenticity with imaginative storytelling.

Benefits of Mixing History and Fantasy

The appeal of historical fantasy goes far beyond its aesthetic charm. It offers a way to make the past feel vivid and alive while introducing magical possibilities. This immersive quality is a cornerstone of the genre. As one RPGPub forum user, Shipyard Locked, puts it:

"That's part of the appeal of the genre, the opportunity to visit the past and have it feel real in a way no fantasy world can really manage."

• Shipyard Locked, RPGPub Forum User

By setting campaigns in historically inspired worlds - like Renaissance Italy infused with magical guilds - players can draw on their knowledge of the period while exploring supernatural twists.

Historical settings also provide a structured framework that sparks creativity. Game Masters and players can engage with history without being bound by its limitations. For instance, a female warrior might defy the societal norms of her time, with magic leveling the playing field.

Another advantage is the natural integration of mythology. By weaving magic and myth into the beliefs and superstitions of a specific era, supernatural elements feel authentic rather than out of place. As RPGnet Administrator TristramEvans explains:

"I like historical fantasy games that run with the premise 'this is our world if what people believed as far as mythology/folklore was true.'"

• TristramEvans, RPGnet Administrator/Moderator

Historical fantasy also invites players to reimagine major events. Whether it’s a magical twist on Caesar’s assassination or a plague altered by sorcery, the possibilities are endless.

For Game Masters, this genre simplifies world-building. As Matt Slater, a philosophy expert, notes:

"It's an easy escape. You don't have to know a lot to create a fantasy world that people can really interact with... It helps to have some background in history and philosophy and anthropology, sure, but it's not necessary. And it takes you away from the world you live in."

• Matt Slater, B.A. in Philosophy

This combination of escapism and real-world engagement allows campaigns to address complex themes like social inequality, religious conflict, or cultural shifts through both historical and magical perspectives.

Compared to pure fantasy, historical fantasy grounds its magical elements in a world that feels familiar, enhancing immersion. While pure historical RPGs might focus on accuracy, the addition of fantasy provides flexibility and creative freedom - even if it bends historical facts. Unlike sci-fi RPGs, which often require intricate world-building of futuristic societies, historical fantasy benefits from our shared understanding of the past, making it more accessible.

Picking the Right Historical Setting

How to Choose Historical Periods

Selecting the right historical period can bring your campaign to life by reinforcing its themes, captivating players, and providing a rich backdrop for storytelling.

Start by identifying the themes you want to explore. For example, the Renaissance offers a perfect setting for stories of political intrigue and artistic innovation, while the Bronze Age - with its mysteries and sparse records - leaves plenty of room for fantasy to flourish. Choose a period that resonates with your players’ interests, whether that’s the chivalry of medieval knights or the seafaring adventures of the Age of Sail. When players are excited about the setting, they’ll naturally engage more deeply with the game.

Historical eras marked by conflict or transformation, such as the Hundred Years’ War, are particularly useful. These times of upheaval provide built-in drama, ready-made plotlines, and character motivations that can easily incorporate fantasy elements. Don’t shy away from lesser-known periods like the Bronze Age collapse or the Islamic Golden Age. These eras often have gaps in historical records, making them ideal for weaving in fantastical elements.

Before finalizing your choice, check the availability of research materials. Popular periods like medieval Europe or ancient Rome are well-documented, making them easier to work with, while more obscure eras may require extra effort to research.

Historian Steffan O’Sullivan puts it best: “History is a wellspring for ideas - not a metaplot”. Instead of treating history as a rigid framework, think of it as a dramatic genre that can enhance your storytelling. Focus on the cinematic potential of your chosen era and how it can amplify your narrative goals.

Once your historical period is set, the next challenge is blending fantasy into the historical backdrop in a way that feels seamless and engaging.

Mixing Historical Facts with Fantasy Elements

With your setting chosen, it’s time to layer in fantasy elements. The key is finding the right balance between historical accuracy and creative freedom. Rather than getting bogged down in strict historical details, focus on creating an atmosphere that feels authentic to the period.

Decide upfront how magic or fantasy will fit into your game. Will it subtly influence events, or will it play a central role, like shaping major battles? Align these choices with your players’ expectations to ensure everyone is on the same page.

Use “what if” scenarios to reimagine history with a fantastical twist. For example, what if a magical curse caused the Black Death? Or what if battle mages turned the tide at the Battle of Hastings? These alternate outcomes allow you to blend history and fantasy in ways that feel fresh and exciting.

When adding historical details, think of them as seasoning - just enough to enhance the flavor without overwhelming the story. As Conrad Kinch advises, “Think of period words as seasoning - a little goes a long way”. Sprinkle in a few era-specific terms or customs each session to give your world depth without drowning players in minutiae.

If you hit a historical snag during gameplay, don’t sweat it. Flexibility is your friend. As Kinch suggests, “If you don’t know an answer to a question, and there’s no compelling reason to say no, go with the answer that best serves the game”. The goal is to create an enjoyable, collaborative experience - not a flawless history lesson.

To make your fantasy elements feel natural, consider using a legend-dominated approach. Incorporate supernatural elements based on the beliefs of the time. If people in your chosen era believed in witches, dragons, or divine intervention, weaving these into your narrative will feel authentic and immersive.

Finally, be sensitive when addressing historical atrocities or delicate topics. Clearly distinguish between fact and fiction, and give players the freedom to decide how they interact with difficult historical realities. Thoughtful handling of these elements can create meaningful connections to the past while respecting its gravity.

How to Use Real History in D&D and TTRPG | Web DM

sbb-itb-b8b00a5

Adding Fantasy to Historical Settings

Once you've chosen your historical period and explored how to blend facts with fantasy, it’s time to dive into the nitty-gritty: weaving magical elements into your setting. The trick? Make the fantasy feel like it belongs - like it’s always been part of that historical world. This section outlines practical ways to seamlessly integrate fantasy into your historical narrative.

Using Magic and Mythology

To make magic feel authentic in a historical setting, align it with the beliefs and cultural norms of the time. By doing this, you create a world that feels grounded, even with fantastical elements.

Start by researching how people in your chosen era understood magic, spirits, and the supernatural. Magic in your story should feel plausible within the historical context. As Shipyard Locked points out:

"Magic in these games should be rare, special and limited. I can just about buy an alternate history with hidden groups of low-powered supernaturals, but anything more than that stretches the likelihood that history would have run the current course."

This means avoiding over-the-top magical systems that would have drastically altered history. Instead, focus on subtle, practical magic. Historically, magic was often tied to healing, protection, and solving everyday problems. For example:

• In a medieval European setting, you might include hedge witches brewing healing potions based on herbal remedies or wise women practicing divination with methods believed to work at the time.
• For a Viking-age campaign, seidr magic could emphasize prophecy and weaving fate rather than destructive spells.

Anchor these magical elements in the superstitions of the era. If your story is set during the Salem witch trials, the fear and paranoia surrounding witchcraft should feel palpable, even if magical practitioners are rare and their powers modest.

Building Alternate Histories

This approach takes things a step further by reimagining key historical events with a magical twist. The goal is to introduce fantastical elements at pivotal moments while still respecting the broader flow of history. The first step? Pinpoint the moment where your world diverges from real history. As Mike Bourke explains:

"Selecting the right departure point, and being willing to put in the research and development time, are all that's needed to shape a culture into whatever the story of the PCs is going to demand."

Once you’ve identified this departure point, carefully map out the ripple effects of your changes. Assume that events untouched by magic would unfold as they did in real life. This balance keeps your setting familiar while allowing for creative liberties.

To maintain historical depth, use the "Substitution Principle." For instance, if a magical plague prevented the Black Death, consider what other social or economic pressures might have arisen in its place.

When adapting historical figures, apply the "Principles of Genius." Assume that brilliant individuals would still achieve great things unless your magical changes directly interfere. For example, Leonardo da Vinci might still be an inventor in your alternate Renaissance, but his creations could be powered by enchanted gears rather than purely mechanical designs.

Think about how magic could reshape social and political structures. Who controls magical knowledge? How does it influence power dynamics, funding for discoveries, or communication between scholars?

For inspiration, look at how creators like J.K. Rowling and Neil Gaiman blend fantasy with real-world settings. Rowling’s Harry Potter series hides a magical world within the modern one, while Gaiman’s American Gods brings mythology into a contemporary landscape. These examples show how to balance the familiar with the fantastical.

Creating Characters and Groups

With your alternate history in place, it’s time to populate your world with characters and factions that fit your magical narrative. The key is adapting historical figures and societal structures while preserving their essence.

Draw from historical governance, class hierarchies, and cultural norms to design magical factions. For example, Joan of Arc could become a mage touched by divine forces, leading a rebellion guided by spiritual visions. Or Genghis Khan might rise as a warlord whose conquests are fueled by a magical prophecy.

Blend traditions from different cultures to craft unique societies. Imagine a seafaring nation that combines Viking longships with Polynesian navigation techniques, enhanced by enchanted stars and magical oars.

Historical conflicts offer ready-made drama. The Crusades could inspire stories of ideological battles in a world where gods directly intervene. Similarly, the French Revolution could be reimagined as a struggle between peasants and magical aristocrats, complete with enchanted guillotines.

"What if" scenarios can also spark creativity. For instance, the invention of the printing press might lead to magical scrolls that replicate themselves, spreading forbidden knowledge and causing upheaval.

As C. Wesley Clough puts it:

"Using real-world history to inspire your fantasy world isn't about copying the past; it's about reimagining it through the lens of your creativity."

Don’t forget to incorporate historical art, fashion, and architecture. Gothic cathedrals could become temples with stained glass that glows with divine light. Renaissance clothing might inspire the attire of a magical aristocracy, featuring enchanted fabrics that shimmer with illusions.

Testing Your Historical Fantasy RPG

Once you've built your historical fantasy world and infused it with magical elements, the next step is putting it to the test: game sessions. Playtesting is where you find out if your blend of history and fantasy works smoothly in action. It’s a chance to refine your mechanics and ensure players enjoy a captivating experience that balances historical depth with magical intrigue. Let’s explore how to test your game mechanics and navigate cultural nuances during play.

Testing Game Mechanics

Start with solo playtesting to get a feel for your framework. Run through character creation, combat scenarios, and magic systems on your own. This helps you identify and fix any glaring issues early on. Once the basics are solid, bring in friends or family for initial testing. These early sessions should focus on understanding the game rather than perfecting every detail.

Blind playtests are a game-changer. Let people from your target audience try the game without instructions. As Brandon Rollins puts it:

"When you give your game to other people with no instructions on how to play. You can choose to observe them while playing or elicit their feedback after the game has ended".

Set clear goals for each playtest. For example, test specific scenarios like the endgame, rare magical phenomena, or historically complex moments. Steve Jackson emphasizes the importance of testing unconventional strategies:

"Playtest the dumb strategies"
to uncover potential system exploits.

Pay attention to pacing, too. If testers feel the game drags, it likely means it’s not engaging enough. As Jackson notes:

"If your testers say it takes too long, what they really mean is they're not having enough fun".

After each session, ask targeted questions to identify areas for improvement. Recording the sessions and using a structured reflection process - like the four F’s: Facts, Feelings, Findings, and Future - can help you analyze feedback effectively.

Handling Culture and Player Input

Beyond mechanics, it’s essential to address cultural nuances and player feedback for a well-rounded experience. While your game may be rooted in history, it’s not a history textbook. Aim for cultural authenticity without being overly rigid. When inaccuracies or anachronisms come up (and they will), handle them with care. One guideline advises:

"It's unavoidable that anachronisms and/or inaccuracies come up from time to time - especially in player roleplaying. It's best to quickly (and gently) course correct then move on".

Set expectations early by encouraging players to immerse themselves in the era’s spirit. Ask them to embrace their character’s perspective and leave modern thinking behind. Conrad Kinch offers a practical tip:

"The trick is to think of period words (and historical content more generally) as a seasoning, a little goes a long way".

Introduce a few period-specific terms each session and use tools like music, photos, or film clips to enhance immersion.

Feedback is key. Use surveys to gather player opinions, with scales like "Greatly", "Somewhat", or "Indifferent" to measure their responses. Frame questions around the overall experience and include prompts like, "What would you like to see more or less of in the campaign?" Starting each session with a recap from a player can also highlight which moments resonated most.

Create an environment where feedback flows freely. As linksassin points out:

"Ultimately how much our players are enjoying the game is the only metric that measures how 'good' we are as a DM. If the players can't communicate what they are enjoying/not enjoying with the DM how can they improve?".

Make changes gradually, implementing one adjustment at a time, and acknowledge player input. For sensitive topics like cultural representation or historical accuracy, consider using anonymous surveys to encourage honest feedback.

Conclusion: Combining History and Fantasy

With your mechanics fine-tuned and your narrative polished, it’s time to bring everything together. Merging history with fantasy is all about finding that sweet spot between authenticity and creativity. Historical details should enhance your story, not overshadow it. As Conrad Kinch aptly puts it, "The aim should be to create an enjoyable collaborative experience, rather than deliver a history lesson".

Focus on making your game feel believable. Research is your backbone, but don’t let it overwhelm you or your players. Subtle magical elements can add intrigue and wonder without breaking immersion - think of them as seasoning rather than the main course.

Keep the player experience at the forefront. Give players the freedom to shape the narrative, weaving their characters’ perspectives into the historical backdrop. Your goal isn’t to recreate history verbatim but to craft a compelling, shared story that feels alive and collaborative.

Flexibility and communication are key. Be clear about your game’s tone and expectations, but stay open to feedback. Some groups may revel in the depth of historical accuracy, while others might prefer a lighter touch that simply evokes the time period. Adjust as needed to suit your players’ preferences. This adaptability ties together everything you’ve worked on during the design and testing phases.

For inspiration, check out the TTRPG Games Directory. It’s packed with examples of games that combine historical settings with fantastical elements, offering insights into mechanics, themes, and storytelling techniques that could spark ideas for your campaign.

With thoughtful preparation, open communication, and a dash of flexibility, you can transform history into a vibrant, imaginative world that invites players to dive in and make it their own.

FAQs

How can I seamlessly combine fantasy elements with a historical setting in my RPG campaign?

To blend fantasy elements with a historical setting effectively, start by diving deep into the historical period you’ve chosen as your backdrop. Familiarize yourself with its major events, cultural practices, and societal structures. This foundation ensures your world feels grounded and believable, even as you layer in fantastical elements.

When introducing fantasy, think about how these elements would naturally fit into the historical context. For instance, if magic exists, how might it shape politics, influence battles, or alter daily routines? If mythical creatures roam the land, consider how societies might adapt - would they view these creatures as threats, allies, or even divine beings? The key is to weave these elements in a way that complements the historical framework rather than overwhelming it.

Consistency is crucial. Every fantastical addition should align with the established tone and internal logic of your world. When done well, this balance creates a setting that feels both immersive and imaginative, offering players an RPG experience they won’t soon forget.

How can I combine historical accuracy with creative freedom in a historical fantasy RPG?

Balancing the demands of historical accuracy with the creative freedom of a historical fantasy RPG means weaving real-world elements into an imaginative narrative. Start by anchoring your setting in a specific historical era or event. This provides a solid foundation and a sense of familiarity. Then, layer in fantastical elements, like magic, mythical beings, or alternate histories, to craft a world that feels both grounded and otherworldly.

To keep the setting authentic, focus on key historical details that give the story depth - things like societal norms, influential figures, or pivotal events. However, don’t be afraid to tweak or reinterpret these elements to suit your story. The aim isn’t to create a history textbook but to capture the essence of the time while allowing room for creative twists and player-driven exploration.

It’s not about achieving perfect historical accuracy. Instead, it’s about blending the spirit of the past with the excitement of a world your players will be eager to dive into.

How can I respectfully include sensitive historical topics in a fantasy RPG setting?

When weaving sensitive historical themes into a fantasy RPG, it’s crucial to approach them with care and respect. A great starting point is holding a Session 0 with your players. This session provides a space for everyone to discuss their boundaries, share comfort levels, and set clear expectations. It’s a simple but effective way to ensure the game remains enjoyable and safe for all participants.

When tackling these topics, focus on their emotional and social impact rather than reducing them to dry facts or trivial details. This approach can add depth to your narrative and create powerful storytelling moments. However, it’s equally important to avoid misrepresentation or causing unnecessary discomfort. The aim is to enhance the richness of the game world while keeping your players engaged and comfortable.

Related posts

• Designing Magic-Infused Ecosystems: Tips for GMs
• Using Real Cultures in RPG World-Building
• 5 Tips for Balancing Story and Mechanics in RPGs
• Fantasy Flora and Fauna: Balancing Realism in RPGs